Would You Rather

3x Cups in a row within the next 10 years implies a certain level of continued dominance that is hard to achieve.

4x Cups (no repeats) within the next 10 years. An extra Cup to show for it, but a less flashy result as 3x in a row.

Which do you choose?

4 in 10 with no repeats. That would be a heck of a decade. 3 in a row might only be three competitive years.

I will be thrilled with 1 cup over the next decade.

One in the next 10 is fine. One in the next 15 is fine.

Two in the next 10 would be amazing.

Three in a row hasnt happened in the cap era.

Four in 10 is incredible and would be as close to a dynasty that you can get in the modern day NHL.

Three in a row has only happened 5x in history. Toronto X2, Montreal X2, Islanders. Only three teams can claim that feat. None in the cap era.

I sacrifice one Cup for the prestige of 3 in a row.

3 peat would be a dynasty. 3 peat would be unprecedented in the modern era. That would be awesome.

But 4 would be fine too lol

4 in a Decade. 3 in a row and not the 4th would always be met by islander fans as one short lol

Would they invoke history? In that case we would say we have 7 cups vs 4. So whatever. GIVE ME A MODERN DAY DYNASTY

Would they invoke history? In that case we would say we have 7 cups vs 4. So whatever. GIVE ME A MODERN DAY DYNASTY

Lol yeah but I’d say 4 cups in 10 years is a dynasty regardless.

Lol yeah but I’d say 4 cups in 10 years is a dynasty regardless.

Both are dynasties for sure, but 3 in a row kind of puts you in rarified conversation as a top dynasty in history. Especially being the first to do it in the modern cap era.

Does you answer change if it's, say, 4 in a row within 15 years versus 5 in 15 with no repeats?

Both are dynasties for sure, but 3 in a row kind of puts you in rarified conversation as a top dynasty in history. Especially being the first to do it in the modern cap era.

 

Does you answer change if it's, say, 4 in a row within 15 years versus 5 in 15 with no repeats?

Yeah because then you’ve tied the most in a row in modern day hockey. Think the Canadians did 5 in a row but in the 50s. At this point I’ll take anything lol

I picked 4 but I honestly don't know which I would prefer. W-L-W-W-L-W would be pretty sweet. I know its not a choice though. Shit, just one W would be sweet.

I don’t want to get ahead of myself with expectations and obviously there’s still much to be done and still many questions and variables, but one can’t deny that it’s going in a very good direction and it seems that they’ll be a serious contender in short order and for a long time

If that winds up being the case, 1 Cup might actually be underachieving

I don’t want to get ahead of myself with expectations and obviously there’s still much to be done and still many questions and variables, but one can’t deny that it’s going in a very good direction and it seems that they’ll be a serious contender in short order and for a long time

 

If that winds up being the case, 1 Cup might actually be underachieving

I'd still be ecstatic with one. That is my point, as was a few others.

I'd still be ecstatic with one. That is my point, as was a few others.

Oh yeah. I’d be thrilled with that too. Just saying things are shaping up well and for there to be the potential for a good shot at more than 1.

I picked 4 but I honestly don't know which I would prefer. W-L-W-W-L-W would be pretty sweet. I know its not a choice though. Shit, just one W would be sweet.

It'll be unreal when (if?) the Rangers actually win again, even if it's just one.

However, we fans deserve a dynasty. I am greedy. I want multiple. I want Yankees late 90s feel up in dis bish.

It'll be unreal when (if?) the Rangers actually win again, even if it's just one.

 

However, we fans deserve a dynasty. I am greedy. I want multiple. I want Yankees late 90s feel up in dis bish.

I so badly want that too.

I love how I am the 3rd or 4th person to say I'd be happy with just one but I am the one getting singled out here. JFC, I played your game, I gave my opinion, and concluded that I would be happy to at least get one given the past 79 years we endured.

Shit!! I'd be glad with one as well!!!!

But 4 in 10 years is definitely a winner!

3 in a row.

then after the 3 in a row we start getting more first overall picks, rebuild it up again and get ready for another 3 peat the next decade