Jump to content
  • Join us — it's free!

    We are the premiere internet community for New York Rangers news and fan discussion. Don't wait — join the forum today!

IGNORED

Malkin Gets Major After Elbowing T.J. Oshie in the Face


Phil

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 52
  • Created
  • Last Reply
The elbow didn't even make contact

Ok, 1 inch above the elbow did. Suspensions are based on intent, and he intended to elbow him in the face.

 

The elbow coming up on the follow through should be an automatic signal that there is malicious intent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, it's not, he's bracing and leaning into the hit.

Bullshit. That subtle shoulder move and leaning into contact is exactly how you wreck a guys face, and a guy with a history of so many cheapshots as Malkin doesn't get the benefit of doubt.

 

Have you ever played football or lacrosse? When you feel contact coming from the side - ball carrier or about to be picked/blocked - you make that subtle lean and raise the shoulder. That is all it takes to blow through contact. The difference is that, in those sports, guys are a) not on ice and b) have facemasks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bullshit. That subtle shoulder move and leaning into contact is exactly how you wreck a guys face, and a guy with a history of so many cheapshots as Malkin doesn't get the benefit of doubt.

 

Have you ever played football or lacrosse? When you feel contact coming from the side - ball carrier or about to be picked/blocked - you make that subtle lean and raise the shoulder. That is all it takes to blow through contact. The difference is that, in those sports, guys are a) not on ice and b) have facemasks.

 

Just because you disagree, doesn't make it bullshit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bullshit. That subtle shoulder move and leaning into contact is exactly how you wreck a guys face, and a guy with a history of so many cheapshots as Malkin doesn't get the benefit of doubt.

 

Have you ever played football or lacrosse? When you feel contact coming from the side - ball carrier or about to be picked/blocked - you make that subtle lean and raise the shoulder. That is all it takes to blow through contact. The difference is that, in those sports, guys are a) not on ice and b) have facemasks.

 

So hockey players aren't allowed to brace for contact and should just take the ass whooping?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oshie shouldn't lead with his face. Wouldn't there be a hearing announced by now if there was a issue with the play?

Well, this has absolutely nothing to do with what Malkin did.

 

But when you start playing this game, it means that the Wilson hit is the product of Sundqvist not picking his head up, and who knows how many other suspensions where they player who got hit put themselves in a bad position.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, this has absolutely nothing to do with what Malkin did.

 

But when you start playing this game, it means that the Wilson hit is the product of Sundqvist not picking his head up, and who knows how many other suspensions where they player who got hit put themselves in a bad position.

 

Except for the key difference.

 

Oshie is the one initiating the contact. He is coming into Malkin's space to defend him. He should be hitting Malkin his his shoulder not his face. This would result in a shoulder to shoulder hit when Malkin braces for impact.

 

Wilson on the other hand comes across the ice from Sundqvist's blind side and initiates the hit with Sundqvist's head as the primary point of contact. If Wilson would have hit him in the body instead of the head there would have been no issue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

way to ignore the entire rest of the post

 

and yea, it does matter. If you go to hit some one, and lead with your face, what do you expect to happen?

What TJ Oshie did doesn't matter, b/c it's separate from Malkin raising his elbow. If a guy goes at you in the corner, you can't just put your elbow up to defend yourself.

 

The Sundqvist argument is bunk, because if he didn't have his head down, the principle point of contact wouldn't be the head. Players are responsible to not hit others in the head, it doesn't matter what the other guy is doing, that's the precedent that the league has set.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He did raise his shoulder (bracing for the collision), not his elbow. His elbow moving is a product of his skating momentum going forward and bracing for the hit that's coming from the right.

No it's not. League got it wrong.

 

I've done this exact thing 500 times, and I guarantee that an athlete of Malkin's quality knew exactly what he was doing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What TJ Oshie did doesn't matter, b/c it's separate from Malkin raising his elbow. If a guy goes at you in the corner, you can't just put your elbow up to defend yourself.

 

The Sundqvist argument is bunk, because if he didn't have his head down, the principle point of contact wouldn't be the head. Players are responsible to not hit others in the head, it doesn't matter what the other guy is doing, that's the precedent that the league has set.

 

Eh, the elbow wasn't really what got engaged there, it was upper arm. I definitely see it as Oshie being low and Malkin bracing for impact.

 

That is not a vicious elbow. It's not Mat Cooke territory.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




×
×
  • Create New...